Best Pizzeria in Holly Hill

Best Restaurant in Holly Hill

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

White base with with grilled chicken, bacon, and a healthy dose of garlic and ranch

Chef Salad

Large. Assorted Italian cold cuts & cheese over our house salad.

Build Your Own Wings (12 Pieces)

Jumbo bone-in wings baked then deep-fried and tossed in your choice of homemade wing sauce.

Texas Burger

A half-pound of ground beef, pattied by hand just like you do at home! Topped with BBQ sauce, Cheddar cheese, onion rings, and topped with a jalapeño popper.

Order From Our Website

Order From Our Website

Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.
Order Now

What our customers are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

We had an absolutely wonderful experience at Neighbors Pizza. The sauce was delicious, the crust was perfect and it reminded me of Long Island pizza which is a rarity in the state of Florida.

Ariana T

Ariana T

I tried this restaurant due to a mailer received. I have since eaten here over and over. Seriously the best pizza, wings, calzone, lasagna, and subs I’ve had in a long time. Well priced and quick pick up. I’ll be honest, the wings are seriously right on point as for crispy and flavor goes. Truly worth checking this place out. You won’t be disappointed. Very much my new favorite hidden gem.

Ryan R

Ryan R

you guys...I can not say enough about this place! their food is always hot and tasty...the order is always right...and the delivery guy found out I have a kidney issue and...yall...he called his momma then made sure to let me know of the remedies she suggested! this is a rough time, especially for delivery drivers and THESE PEOPLE CARE♥️

April M

April M

Featuring

Healthy Options

Easy Parking

Only Fresh Ingredients

Only Fresh Ingredients
We invest in quality ingredients to ensure our customers get the great taste we’re famous for. Because we believe that you deserve the best.

Made With Love

Made With Love
Our secret ingredient is passion. Everyone on our team is passionate about making your time with us as great as it can be – from start to finish.
Neighbors Pizza Rewards

Neighbors Pizza Rewards

Join our rewards program to earn points, get free items, and stay up to date with us.

Come Visit Us!

Come Visit Us!
What's not to love about hand-tossed dough and scratch-made sauce piled high with your favorite toppings? Around here, pizza is our passion, and people are our priority, so we make sure every pie is packed with fresh ingredients, filled with flavor, and served with a smile. As a staple of our community since 1987, we continue to serve folks from all walks of life as they stop by for a New York-style slice or hot sub served on a roll from our local bakery, Sorento's. Come see for yourself just what we mean when we say we're taking pizza to the next level.

Frequently asked questions

Our location